Rantanen, McDavid Or Nylander: Who Are The Early Conn Smythe Favorites?

Terrence Lee-Imagn Images

The Conn Smythe Trophy does not get awarded in the first or second round of the playoffs. But less than three weeks into the post-season, it's already clear that some players have emerged as early MVP favorites.

Here's a look at five who are leading their teams to what they hope will be an eventual Stanley Cup — that is, if they can advance to the third and final rounds.

Mikko Rantanen

What else is there to say about the man called Moose?

Rantanen, who singlehandedly brought the Dallas Stars back from the dead in Game 7 against the Avalanche with a hat trick in the third period, followed it up with another “hatty” in Game 1 against Winnipeg. He now leads the playoffs with eight goals — two of which are game-winners — and 15 points in eight games.

Maybe he’s still motivated by the ugly trade that sent him from Colorado-to-Carolina-to-Dallas. Or maybe he’s trying to justify the eight-year, $96-million contract extension he just signed.

Either way, the league’s most underrated superstar is no longer underrated anymore.

'He Was Feeling It': William Nylander Sets The Tone For Maple Leafs Against Panthers'He Was Feeling It': William Nylander Sets The Tone For Maple Leafs Against PanthersThe Toronto Maple Leafs surprised a lot of people by taking Game 1 of their second-round series against the defending Stanley Cup-champion Florida Panthers.

William Nylander

Some players shrink when playing under the bright lights of Toronto. Others feed off the pressure.

“Willy Styles” is in the latter camp.

You can say what you want about the Maple Leafs’ inability to get over the hump in the playoffs. But before you lump Nylander with the other members of the Core Four, keep this in mind: in the past six years, Nylander has scored 23 goals and 45 points in 42 games.

This year, Nylander is once again producing when it matters the most.

After leading all Toronto players with 45 goals in the regular season — his third straight 40-goal season — the 29-year-old has a team-leading eight goals and 13 points in eight games. In the process, he has helped the Leafs to a 2-0 series lead against Florida, while also helping veteran linemates’ John Tavares (three goals and five points) and Max Pacioretty (two goals and six points) turn back the clock.

Max Pacioretty Reinvents Himself With Toronto Maple LeafsMax Pacioretty Reinvents Himself With Toronto Maple LeafsMax Pacioretty wasn’t the Toronto Maple Leafs’ Masterton Award nominee, but he’s making a big impact in his comeback.

Connor McDavid

A year ago, McDavid led the playoffs in scoring with 42 points in 25 games. So it’s not exactly surprising that the Edmonton Oilers captain already has 13 points in seven games. What might be noteworthy is that 12 of those points have come in even-strength situations.

That’s more than anyone has scored in 5-on-5.

As opponents know, you can’t stop McDavid. All you can really do is limit his production. Even then, good luck.

After going without a point in Game 2 of a first-round series against the LA Kings, McDavid has been riding a six-game point streak, with nine points during that span. So what if he only has two goals. When you’re on a team that also includes Leon Draisaitl (four goals and 12 points), you don’t need to always be the one scoring.

Kyle Connor

It was Winnipeg's Cole Perfetti who forced overtime in Game 7 against the St. Louis Blues, and it was Adam Lowry who scored the eventual series winner. But in a playoffs where Mark Scheifele has battled injury and Connor Hellebuyck has battled the ghosts of post-seasons' past, Connor has been the steady leader.

All he does is produce. And he tends to produce when it matters the most.

Connor, who led the Jets with 41 goals and 97 points in the regular season, has four goals and 12 points in eight playoff games. Two of his goals have been game-winners.

In Game 7, he set up three goals as Winnipeg did the improbable and came back 4-3 against St. Louis.

"You’re not just going to sit there and sulk,” Connor told reporters. “You have to do anything you can to help the team push forward."

NHL Playoffs 2025: Winners And Losers From Round 1 Feature Rantanen, Necas And MoreNHL Playoffs 2025: Winners And Losers From Round 1 Feature Rantanen, Necas And MoreJust like that, the NHL’s 2025 Stanley Cup playoff field is cut in half. 

Andrei Svechnikov

The Hurricanes are not a star-driven team. That's mostly by design.

The reason why Mikko Rantanen never really found a home in Carolina is because coach Rod Brind'Amour prefers to roll four lines rather than relying on one or two players to get the win.

And yet, where would Carolina be without Svechnikov? The Russian winger only had 20 goals in the regular season, but in the playoffs he's enjoying a sort of coming-out-party with five goals and six points in six games. Those aren't Rantanen-like numbers.

But on a team where everyone is expected to chip in, Svechnikov is chipping in a little bit more than everyone else. It's why the Hurricanes rolled over the Devils in the first round and also why they grabbed a 1-0 series lead against the Capitals in the second round.

Will The Coaching Carousel Cost The Canadiens?

Laval Rocket coach Pascal Vincent. Photo Credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

There are a lot of vacancies in the NHL team's coaching department. As things stand, the Anaheim Ducks, Boston Bruins, Chicago Blackhawks, Philadelphia Flyers, Pittsburgh Penguins, Seattle Kraken, and Vancouver Canucks are all without a permanent head coach right now.

Canadiens: Caufield Speaks To The Media
Canadiens’ Farm Team Laval Rocket Through To Round Three
Canadiens: About That Crosby Pipe Dream...

Meanwhile, Montreal Canadiens’ coach Martin St-Louis has been nominated for the Jack Adams Trophy alongside Scott Arniel and Spencer Carbery. Meanwhile, Pascal Vincent, who’s at the helm of the Laval Rocket, has been named coach of the year in the AHL.

Before joining the Rocket, Vincent coached the Columbus Blue Jackets. He was put in a less-than-ideal position, leading the Ohio outfit to a 27-43-12 record with a .402 points percentage and finishing dead last in the Metropolitan Division.

A year later, he’s in charge of the Canadiens’ affiliate in the AHL and had his team winning the regular season championship and currently coasting to the third round of the playoffs. Canadiens GM Kent Hughes has already said he won’t stand in Vincent’s way, if a team wants to speak to the Laval coach, they’ll be allowed to, and it will be up to Vincent to decide when they can do that.

Speaking to the media, Vincent explained:

If an (NHL) team wants my services, they will have to be patient. Usually when you really want someone, you can wait one week, two weeks, three weeks or even a month…Just to be interviewed for a head coaching job in the (NHL) is an immense privilege…But for now, my focus is on the boys (in Laval).
- Pascal Vincent on teams being interested in his services. 

While it's reassuring to hear the coach is entirely focused on the Rocket’s destiny right now, it certainly doesn’t sound like a man who’s not interested in making the jump. It would be a shame for the Canadiens to lose him, but you can’t stop a man from moving up in the world.


Canadiens stories, analysis, breaking news, and more! Tap the star to add us to your favorites on Google News, never to miss a story.  

Follow Karine on X @KarineHains Bluesky @karinehains.bsky.social and Threads @karinehains.

Bookmark The Hockey News Canadiens' page for all the news and happenings around the Canadiens.

Ex-Avalanche Mikko Rantanen Breaks Out In Big Way

Mikko Rantanen (Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images)

Gone to another team, but (definitely) not forgotten.

The Colorado Avalanche are still licking their wounds from a heartbreaking Game 7 loss to Mikko Rantanen and the Dallas Stars.

Bookmark The Hockey News Colorado Avalanche team site so you never miss the latest newsgame day coverage, and information on the Avalanche players.

The Stars have a two-game win streak, in no small part due to the play of the former Avalanche superstar.

In Game 1 against the Winnipeg Jets, Rantanen scored another hat trick. This hat trick is more impressive for several reasons.

Trending Avalanche Stories

Andy O'Brien On MacKinnon & The Energy That Goes Into Being EliteAndy O'Brien On MacKinnon & The Energy That Goes Into Being Elite“The word high performance gets thrown around a lot.”

Ex-Avalanche Goalie Sticking With His New Team

Avs Eye-Opening Trade Makes Even Less Sense Now

Avalanche Star Is Recruiting Crosby According To Insider

Avalanche's Makar Is Potential Witness In Hockey Canada Trial

Former Avalanche Defender New Coaching CandidateFormer Avalanche Defender New Coaching CandidateWhen your team doesn’t perform, firing the coach is typically the first move in a GM’s arsenal.

The first reason is that Rantanen is the third player in NHL playoff history to record hat tricks in back-to-back games. The other two players to do it were Jari Kurri during the 1985 playoffs and Doug Bentley in 1944.

The second reason is Rantanen's involvement in all of the Stars’ goals. He has factored in each of the Stars’ last 12 goals, the longest streak in playoff history. Heading into Wednesday night’s game, he was tied with Mario Lemieux for the longest streak (nine goals).

Finally, Rantanen broke some Stars’ records. He became the first Stars player to record a natural hat trick in a playoff game. He scored his hat trick within eight minutes during the second period to lead his new team to a 3-2 victory.

His recent playoff accomplishments leave a bittersweet taste in the mouths of Avalanche fans. On the one hand, it's great for him to have success with his new club. On the other hand, it’s with a different team.

While the Avalanche contemplate what went wrong this season, at least Rantanen is experiencing a new, rejuvenated life in Dallas.

Add us to your Google News favorites and never miss a story.