During a virtual Q&A with selected season ticket members, New York Islanders general manager Mathieu Darche stated that he didn't have any plans to bring in any players on a PTO.
So, if the Islanders aren't going to bring in any players on PTOs, then we have the list of players who will be battling out this fall at training camp.
PTO stands for Professional Tryout, which is when a franchise brings in a player, usually a veteran, on a trial period.
We saw this happen with the Islanders last season when Matt Martin, now a special assistant to Darche, came to camp on a PTO. Due to injuries, Martin was then signed to a one-year deal.
Darche Isn’t Lou — And That’s The Point, Especially When It Comes To Coaching PhilosophyOn Wednesday, New York Islanders general manager
Mathieu Darche joined
Jeff Marek on Daily Faceoff's "The Sheet".
Here's the Islanders' depth chart when it comes to NHL options for 2025-26:
C: Bo Horvat, Mathew Barzal, Calum Ritchie (waiver exempt), Jean-Gabriel Pageau, Casey Cizikas, Kyle MacLean
LW: Jonathan Drouin, Anders Lee, Anthony Duclair, Emil Heineman, Pierre Engvall
RW: Kyle Palmieri, Simon Holmstrom, Maxim Shabanov (waiver exempt), Maxim Tsyplakov, Marc Gatcomb
LD: Alexander Romanov, Adam Pelech, Matthew Schaefer, Isaiah George (waiver exempt)
RD: Tony DeAngelo, Ryan Pulock, Scott Mayfield, Adam Boqvist, Ethan Bear
G: Ilya Sorokin, Semyon Varlamov (IR), David Rittich
I*f Varlamov isn't ready, Rittich will serve as the backup.
We listed 27 players, with NHL rosters maxing out at 23, which means four players from this list will not be making the club this fall.
As of right now, the extra forwards are MacLean, Engvall, and Gatcomb.
If Ritchie wins a job—whether that's as a starting center (which would be tough unless the Islanders decide to keep Barzal on Horvat's wing or move a player like Cizikas to the wing, a place he played a lot last season)—that could push MacLean out of the NHL picture.
MacLean, who is entering the second season of a three-year deal worth $775,000 annually, will need to have a big camp after struggling in 2024-25.
It doesn't make much sense for Ritchie to make the team as an extra, since the club could send him down to Bridgeport and let him develop under Rocky Thompson, serving as the first call-up if there's an injury to the forward group.
So, if Ritchie starts in Bridgeport, that could mean MacLean still has a spot.
With the way Gatcomb played last season, he is kind of a perfect extra forward to have on this roster and will be gunning for a fourth-line gig. He signed a one-year deal worth $900,000 as an RFA.
Engvall is one of the more intriguing players entering training camp. He no question had a strong finish to the season, but his inconsistencies make him a tough player to rely on. Yes, he has five seasons left on his deal at $3 million annually, but that cap hit didn't stop the Islanders from waiving him following last year's camp and again during the season, before ultimately recalling him.
If in Bridgeport, the Islanders can bury $1.15 million of the $3 million, leaving Engvall on the books at $1.85 million.
When it comes to the extra defenseman, it seems like Schaefer and George will be battling out for the final left-side spot.
That doesn't mean if Schaefer makes the team out of camp, there's no value in him being an extra—we saw the Islanders go that route with Noah Dobson. If George doesn't make the team, he will be playing top minutes in Bridgeport.
On the right side, Boqvist is likely making the team, whether that's as the bottom-pairing right-side defenseman or as the club's seventh defenseman. Boqvist, who signed a one-year extension, will have to beat out Scott Mayfield for the bottom-pairing gig, something he did last season following the NHL's 4 Nations Face-Off.
Bear, who signed a one-year, two-way deal worth $775,000, is trying to prove that he is an NHL-quality defenseman and will be gunning for a role.
So, to sum up the roster spot battles, it's the following:
Defense: Schaefer vs. George & Boqvist vs. Bear (any could serve as the extra defenseman if they don't win a starting spot)
Forwards: Engvall vs. Gatcomb, Ritchie vs. MacLean
Goaltenders: Varlamov vs. injury
When it comes to the actual starting lineup, there's more competition.
The only thing known at this time about the lineup is that Drouin will be playing with Horvat. We can project the starting lineup, but there are countless configurations that head coach Patrick Roy will need to figure out:
Drouin - Horvat - Palmieri
Lee - Barzal - Holmstrom
Duclair - Pageau - Shabanov
Heineman - Cizikas - Tsyplakov
Romanov - DeAngelo
Pelech - Pulock
Schaefer - Mayfield
Sorokin
Rittich
This will be an enormous camp for Duclair, who is under contract for three more seasons at $3.5 million. He walked away from the team with eight games to go after trying to get back to his game following an early-season groin injury.
If he can show that his strides are back to where they need to be, he's certainly an option to play with Barzal, which was the thought when he was signed to his deal last July.
For Shabanov, this will be his first taste of the NHL game, and it wouldn't be a shock to see him begin his career in the bottom six before working his way up, if he earns more playing time.
Maxim Tsyplakov, who signed a two-year extension worth $2.25 million annually, went through the growing pains of the NHL this past year and should have more of an understanding of how he has to play to be most effective on the ice.
Shabanov coming over, along with Drouin, certainly pushes Tsyplakov down the forward depth chart. But given Tsyplakov's hockey IQ, physicality, and ability to dish the puck and score, he could be a player who sees time in the middle six.
Simon Holmstrom, who signed a two-year extension worth $3.625 million annually, proved last season that he has the potential to be a true top-six forward after a few seasons of being a third-line shutdown forward.
He probably isn't a top-line winger, so Barzal's wing certainly makes a ton of sense.
If the Islanders have Lee, their captain, in a bottom-six role this season, that's a good sign, as it would mean that Drouin and Duclair are both providing the offense needed for their respective potential roles.
Whether it's for the final roster spots or starting minutes, training camp this fall will be a competitive one. So, buckle up, as we are about a month and a half away.