TORONTO - The Maple Leafs thought they had it figured out.
During the lockout-shortened 2013 season, James Reimer performed well as the team's undisputed starting goalie. A 2.46 goals-against average and .924 save percentage were career bests for the Manitoba native. He also helped Toronto grab its only playoff berth since 2004.
Despite his exploits, the Leafs added "depth" in the crease by acquiring Jonathan Bernier from the Los Angeles Kings that June. It was a trade that didn’t necessarily sit well with Reimer, but given his character and professionalism, he took it in stride. After one season behind Bernier, Reimer and the Maple Leafs agreed to a two-year, $4.6-million contract.
Along the way, though, Toronto's goaltending plan fell apart.
Best laid plans ...
After a strong first season, and a so-so second season, Bernier struggled to begin 2015-16. Freshly signed to a two-year, $8.3-million extension, he gave up questionable goals early in games, and went winless in his first 11 starts. It was a nightmare first impression to deliver to new head coach Mike Babcock.
When Reimer was thrust into duty, he took advantage, posting career-high numbers. His play cast further doubt on the future in Toronto's crease.
Modest return
Given the Maple Leafs' return for trading Reimer to the San Jose Sharks on Saturday - at best a third-round draft pick - the team's future, and vision, in goal is hazier than ever.
"We needed to take a look at our minor-league goalies who are playing extremely well,” Maple Leafs general manager Lou Lamoriello said on a conference call. "We have to look at Garret Sparks right now and see (if) how he performed earlier is something that is the real thing."
Sparks was summoned to back up Bernier for Toronto's game in Montreal on Saturday night. He is 3-1 with a .915 save percentage in his rookie season.
A pick and perhaps an open door
What Toronto received for Reimer pales in comparison to the two second-round draft picks it acquired from San Jose earlier in the week in a trade for Roman Polak and Nick Spaling. But with so many moves being made and so few suitors looking for a goaltender, the Maple Leafs felt it necessary to get a return on their best goaltender right now.
Reimer is an unrestricted free agent this summer. Although the door is potentially open for him to come back, the salary cap trumps all.
"It's certainly behind your mind and I think that's the best I can answer that," Lamoriello said regarding Reimer’s possible return. "I think in this world ... where the cap is ... whatever transpires with the salaries is going to be more prevalent than it has been in the past."
Translation: Reimer is only coming back at the right price and term. Given that both sides were far apart on that front, moving Reimer was Toronto's way of delaying the decision.
Related: Reimer 'definitely' open to possible Toronto return
Playoffs and uncertainty
Reimer joins San Jose with a shot at returning to the playoffs. Although it appears he'll back up Martin Jones to begin his Sharks career, Reimer's .918 save percentage in front of an awful Toronto team is better than Jones' .916 in front of a team in playoff position.
"Obviously I had a lot of good years (in Toronto). It's definitely a weird feeling to be going somewhere else," Reimer said, also thanking the media and fans for how he was treated. "You guys are great. Thank you for all you guys did."
Toronto’s biggest unknown: Who will start the 2016-17 season as the team’s staring goalie? With Reimer out of the picture in the short term, the possibilities seem endless, but the ideal solution far away.
Copyright © 2016 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.