Tale of the tape: How the Habs, Preds, Subban, and Weber have fared since the trade

P.K. Subban and Shea Weber will square off against their former clubs when the Montreal Canadiens host the Nashville Predators on Saturday night.

The franchise defensemen were famously traded for each other in June 2016, and their careers took on different trajectories afterward.

Below, we review how the Predators and Canadiens - along with Subban and Weber - have fared since the blockbuster deal.

Team statistics

Category Predators Canadiens
Overall record 73-41-21 69-52-15
Winning percentage 54 50
Goals for 406 368
Goals against 362 369
Power-play opportunities 443 394
Power-play goals 92 81
Power-play percentage 20.7 20.5
Power-play opportunities against 435 421
Power-play goals allowed 80 85
Penalty-kill percentage 81.7 79.9

Upon first glance, it would appear Nashville merely possesses a slight edge over Montreal. However, if you consider the Canadiens flew out of the gate last season to a 13-1-1 mark before their record stabilized, the disparity between the two teams becomes more evident. The Predators ultimately went to the Stanley Cup Final last season and few would be surprised to see them playing again this June with another shot at the title. Meanwhile, the Canadiens have devolved into disarray, toiling near the bottom of the Eastern Conference.

Subban vs. Weber

Category Subban Weber
Games played 119 104
Goals 25 23
Assists 58 35
Points 83 58
Power-play Goals 7 14
Plus-Minus 3 12
Corsi For % (5-on-5) 53.61 52.18
Points/60 (5-on-5) 1.07 0.85
PDO (5-on-5) 100.16 100.32

Many wondered why Montreal would trade a younger, healthier defenseman nearing his apex in Subban for a player in the latter stages of his prime in Weber. And Subban has been the far superior player since the deal, although Weber's totals have been inflated by an unsustainable 12 power-play goals he scored in 2016-2017. The tale of the tape appears closer than expected on the surface, but the Predators should still be tried for grand larceny after stealing Subban away - a hypothesis supported by statistics, the eye test, and team performance.

Copyright © 2018 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.

Leave a Reply